How It Works
The Authentication & Grading Process
From submission to certified grade — here's exactly what happens to your card at Nerd's Eye Authentication.
Step by Step
The Process
Submit Your Cards
Reach out via our contact form or Instagram DM to start the process. Tell us what you have and we'll confirm availability and turnaround time. Cards are accepted in person in Rocklin or by secure mail.
Initial Inspection
Every card is first checked for authenticity. We compare it against known genuine specimens, checking print quality, card stock, holo patterns, and other authentication markers specific to each game and set.
Structural Grading
We examine the card under magnification across four key areas: corners, edges, surface condition, and centering. Each area is scored individually before arriving at a final composite grade.
Tier Assignment
Based on the structural assessment, your card is assigned one of our six tier levels — from Gem Mint (GEM-MNT) down to Very Good (VG) — with a full written explanation of the grade.
Documentation & Return
You receive a detailed grade report for each card. Cards are returned securely packaged with protective sleeves and top loaders. We treat every card as if it were our own.
Grading Scale
Card Tier Levels
Every card receives one of five tier designations based on its physical condition.
Gem Mint
Perfect condition. No visible flaws under magnification. The highest possible grade.
Mint
Near-perfect condition with only the most minute imperfections visible under close inspection.
Near Mint
Virtually perfect with only the slightest imperfections visible under close inspection.
Near Mint
Minor wear on edges or corners. Still excellent condition and high collector value.
Excellent Near Mint
Noticeable wear but structurally sound. Playable condition with moderate collector value.
Very Good
Significant wear, creases, or damage. Reduced value but still authenticated.
Accepted Card Types
We Grade Them All
Pricing
Simple, Transparent Pricing
Pricing is based on card type and turnaround time. Contact us for a quote — we'll give you a clear breakdown before you commit to anything.
Real Results
See It In Action
A look at real grading reports — detailed analysis, radar scoring, and condition breakdowns for every card we authenticate.
